For me, I was pretty surprised about Atticus being a skilled marksman. So far in the book, all we've seen him is Scout and Jem's tolerant father with high morals and all, not some kind of hunter or anything. We don't know very much about Mrs. Dubose yet, and maybe Scout and Jem don't either, so perhaps they're being ignorant of why she's treating them that way. Maybe there's a reason why she's so mean, and we don't know yet, but for the moment, it's really easy to hate her. Atticus says that she's sick and Scout and Jem shouldn't be saying things about a sick old lady. It's possible she either wants Jem to read to her for a month out of spite and wants to enjoy his misery, or Atticus is correct and she actually is sick and lonely and all. Again, at the moment, it's really easy to hate her, saying horrible things about Scout and Jem when all they do is try to say good morning to her or pass by her house, and going as far as talking about their mother and Atticus lawing for African American "trash" might be crossing a line. Comment below if you agree that it's easy to hate Dubose, even if we don't know the full story yet, if there is one anyway.
Reflections on Harper Lee's classic novel "To Kill a Mockingbird" from Blessed Trinity 8th graders.
Wednesday, November 7, 2018
End of Chapter 10/Start of 11
For me, I was pretty surprised about Atticus being a skilled marksman. So far in the book, all we've seen him is Scout and Jem's tolerant father with high morals and all, not some kind of hunter or anything. We don't know very much about Mrs. Dubose yet, and maybe Scout and Jem don't either, so perhaps they're being ignorant of why she's treating them that way. Maybe there's a reason why she's so mean, and we don't know yet, but for the moment, it's really easy to hate her. Atticus says that she's sick and Scout and Jem shouldn't be saying things about a sick old lady. It's possible she either wants Jem to read to her for a month out of spite and wants to enjoy his misery, or Atticus is correct and she actually is sick and lonely and all. Again, at the moment, it's really easy to hate her, saying horrible things about Scout and Jem when all they do is try to say good morning to her or pass by her house, and going as far as talking about their mother and Atticus lawing for African American "trash" might be crossing a line. Comment below if you agree that it's easy to hate Dubose, even if we don't know the full story yet, if there is one anyway.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I was also surprised that Atticus used to be a marksman. I thought he had simply lived a quiet, somewhat boring life. Also, I have the same feelings or Mrs. DuBose. What type of person yells at a kid for saying good morning? That is just mean. However, there might be a reason to her anger, we just need to wait.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, I don't find it's easy to hate Dubose. Because as you said, we don't know the full story of why she's so miserable and very rude to others, especially the children. I wonder maybe it's because she is just really lonely and unhappy, because she always is rude when she sees Jem and Scout together, and people having a smile/happy. She might feel this way, because she might miss her husband, and after he had died, she became unhappy, and angry to see others happy.
ReplyDeleteI really was surprised when we learned that atticus was a skilled hunter. I thought he only was a lawyer. I also find it easy to hate her because, she isn't a child who doesn't know what she is saying. I cant believe she called atticus trash even though he is nothing but nice to her.
ReplyDelete